In higher education, student success is a widely used yet insufficiently defined concept. While some students equate success with academic performance, others view it through lenses of personal development, career preparation, or perseverance in overcoming obstacles. These varied definitions are shaped by diverse personal, environmental, and institutional contexts (Cao et al., 2024). For faculty to support students meaningfully, they must look beyond standardized measures and engage in conversations that honor individual aspirations and challenges. In my own teaching, I’ve observed how goals can vary significantly—from degree completion among first-generation students to skill advancement for mid-career professionals. Recognizing that failure can also be formative, professors have a unique opportunity to foster inclusive, goal-oriented environments. Effective engagement begins with understanding each student’s pathway and committing to their holistic success. By cultivating this awareness, professors can implement intentional strategies in the classroom that support short-term academic success while laying the groundwork for long-term personal and professional growth.