Beyond Transactional Assignments: Prompting Meaningful Student Work

Credit: iStock.com/marchmeena29
Credit: iStock.com/marchmeena29
We all do it. The semester is drawing to a close, the students are tired, we’re tired. There’s one more assignment to hand out, that major project that’s supposed to somehow capture from the entirety of students’ learning from the past semester. Back in week 1, we had some glorious ideas for that assignment, but now that it’s week 11? Not so much. So the next day in class, we hand out what I’ve come to call The Generic Paper. Or The Generic Oral Presentation. Or The Generic Poster Presentation. You get the point. The genre and medium may change, but the prompt always begins the same way: “Choose a topic that interests you.”

To continue reading, you must be a Teaching Professor Subscriber. Please log in or sign up for full access.

One Response

  1. Great article. Thanks, Paul. The issues you raise are multiplied in much of the Majority World, where students are completely lost in vague general choice, and more directive approaches to learning tasks are imperative. Having taught for over 20 years in Syria and Lebanon I came to realise that the following led to much more satisfying results: very detailed and clear instructions in the syllabus, often with a variety of feed-forward samples of what good work might look like; one-on-one discussion with students about potential topics and strategies; time in class for students to discuss with their peers what they were doing; and a clear checklist cum rubric of what I was looking for. Some of these would probably be beneficial in “Western” contexts as well.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Articles

I have two loves: teaching and learning. Although I love them for different reasons, I’ve been passionate about...
Deadlines are a blessing and a curse. We need them to get things done, but they often loom...
In the Oxford English Dictionary, the most fitting definition of the word light-hearted (sic)for my purposes is this...
A variety of factors can undermine performance on a test beyond lack of knowledge, such as anxiety and...
During my first few years of teaching, I made the classic mistake of adopting a “covering content” mentality....
In higher education, student success is a widely used yet insufficiently defined concept. While some students equate success...
Higher education faculty work with a wide range of adults, from first-year undergraduates to advanced graduate students to...

Create a free account, or log in.

Gain access to limited free articles, news alerts, and select newsletters

Login here